Why Boston Dynamics' backflipping borg shouldn't scare you

Ruse of the Machines

It's alive, it's terrifying, and it does perfect backflips! Boston Dynamics' gymnastic research robot Atlas has caused a minor panic on social media. With skills like this, surely humans are doomed?

Here it is.

Youtube Video

And here's Boston's Mini Spot.

Youtube Video

But hold on. What could this be? It's one of Boston's robots set a slightly more difficult, real-world challenge:

And here's one of their party performers attempting to negotiate the extremely difficult challenge of walking very slowly in a straight line.

Youtube Video

[Skip to 4.08]

Boston's robots are showpieces of anthropomorphism, embedded with complexity that is largely superfluous. Let's do a thought experiment for a moment. Given the job of moving a package of a certain weight over these obstacles, how would you design a machine to do it?

You'd probably settle on a spring for propulsion and some counterweights. You wouldn't need the fancy joints. You certainly wouldn't need the backflip. You wouldn't need the cute anthropomorphic wobble. In fact, you could?actually do it for a fraction of the cost and the complexity. So what's the point? The anthropomorphism actually is the point. It's why Boston's work may be a boon for prosthetics but has little do with the future of robotics, which have to learn about and meet challenges.

For all the talk of a New Machine Age? or the Fourth Industrial Revolution?, someone seems to have forgotten to bring the machines.

We're not the only people to notice a gap between hype and reality. The Wall Street Journal has noticed too. In its article "How to Survive a Robot Apocalypse: Just Close the Door", it notes the many ways robots can be thwarted. More examples are posted on Reddit's Shitty Robots.

Some become quite public.

So 30 years after Moravec's Paradox, computers still excel at adult-level games, and struggle with real-world situations. Moravec rules, OK? ?


Biting the hand that feeds IT ? 1998–2017

                                    1. 621831382 2018-02-23
                                    2. 92331381 2018-02-23
                                    3. 5326071380 2018-02-23
                                    4. 4019031379 2018-02-23
                                    5. 8895891378 2018-02-23
                                    6. 9775451377 2018-02-23
                                    7. 298541376 2018-02-23
                                    8. 513211375 2018-02-23
                                    9. 2105531374 2018-02-23
                                    10. 4906741373 2018-02-23
                                    11. 567831372 2018-02-23
                                    12. 5043271371 2018-02-23
                                    13. 2028341370 2018-02-23
                                    14. 3654301369 2018-02-23
                                    15. 2905181368 2018-02-23
                                    16. 5929231367 2018-02-23
                                    17. 7852051366 2018-02-23
                                    18. 3874991365 2018-02-23
                                    19. 9394591364 2018-02-22
                                    20. 3676521363 2018-02-22